Beauty People Square Edge Eyeliner~

It's the Beauty People eyeliner. Also known as the "ironclad woman" eyeliner.

They said it absolutely wouldn't smudge, but it's smudging lol

The host applied it to their eyes and blinked like crazy, but it didn't smudge at all. So why does it smudge for me? It just keeps smudging, haha.

I want to cry. I bought a set and have several of them. I feel bad giving them to anyone, so I'm just keeping them. Am I missing something?

No matter what I do, it keeps spreading for me. I guess this is what you call a failed item, right?

I do not recommend it unless your face gets extremely dry after applying makeup.