Recommendations for long-lasting pencil eyeliners!

I recommend the Clio Sharp So Simple Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner! Pencil types tend to smudge too easily on my eyes, so I usually only used brush-pen types, but I've been using this product well because it smudges less even though it's a pencil! I use both #1 Black and #2 Brown depending on the occasion. I recommend it~~