I recommend the McQueen Eye Strong Eyebrow Pencil (Hard Powder).

McQueen New York My Strong Eyebrow Pencil Hard Powder makes your eyebrows look natural, just like your own.

There are 5 types: Soft Beige, Walnut Brown, Natural Brown, Gray Brown, and Stone Gray.

The Walnut Brown I use is a light brown color that suits light brown tones or light dyed hair, creating a softer look.

The hard powder formula keeps your eyebrows neat from morning to evening by controlling oil and moisture to keep them matte.

I liked it because the color payoff was good, it was easy to apply, and it looked completely natural.