Eyeliner I bought with my own money

This is the Benefit Bad Gal Eyeliner in Deep Brown, which I bought with my own money. It is a convenient automatic pencil type that doesn't require sharpening, and it has a sponge-like smudge tip attached to the back. It is firm so there is no powder fallout, and it applies smoothly with excellent spreadability, yet it smudges almost completely. It applies cleanly and has good staying power. The sponge attached to the back of the pencil is great for creating a natural gradient effect.