Clio Extreme Gelpresso Pencil Liner

I like it because it applies creamily and doesn't smudge.
If you draw or apply it to the mucous membrane and open your eyes immediately

There may be a slight transfer under or above the eyes, but

Still, it seems to offer excellent performance for the price.

The staying power isn't bad, and it doesn't smudge much.

It is an incredibly soft pencil liner, so it is very comfortable to use when filling in the mucous membrane.
However, since the pencil tip is a bit thick, I think you might find it a little difficult to draw a thin line 😢