I like Merzy products for eye makeup.

I use Merzy eyeliner,

I use Merzy eyebrow pencil. For me, this product doesn't smudge at all.

And for eyebrows, it's Clio Kill Lash!!

I've settled on this for now, but I'm willing to switch if something better comes along.

Of all the ones I've written so far, these are my favorites.

Oh, and for my lower lashes, I use Etude House mascara!! It doesn't smudge and the price is good, so I use it all the time >.<