Eyeliner I've been using for 4 years

I stumbled upon this eyeliner by chance, and I've been using it for four years now! It's The Face Shop Ink Gel Pencil Liner. The capacity is huge, so once you buy it, it really feels like it lasts for over a year. Also, since I have oily skin that tends to smudge easily, this doesn't smudge and has great staying power. This is the thicker version, but there is also a thin, slim version! I recommend the brown shade for a natural eye makeup look.