The First Gel Eyeliner

It's The First Gel Eyeliner in Soft Brown.

I bought it because the color was brown, and it is very soft.

Being soft could be an advantage, but it's so soft that it's hard to sharpen and use.

And I apply it, but by the afternoon, it has smudged under my eyes.

I don't use it often because it smudges under my eyes.

I have no intention of repurchasing.