Lilybyred Starry Eyes Nine to Nine Slim Gel Eyeliner

Lilybyred Starry Eyes Nine to Nine Slim Gel Eyeliner 01#Matte Black

It's a slim gel eyeliner, so it draws a nice, slim line.

It doesn't come off easily until I wipe it off, and the waterproof effect is good.

It applies smoothly, doesn't smudge, and has decent staying power. It creates a natural look with black.