Eyeliner I bought with my own money: Lilybyred Starry Eyes Nine to Nine Gel Eyeliner

This is an eyeliner I bought with my own money. The product I am using is the Lilybyred Gel Eyeliner. Since it is a pencil type, it is easy to draw with and I like that it doesn't smudge. Once I finish drawing, it tends to stay in place well. The shade I am using is Matte Brown. I think the color is perfect for creating different eye looks. If you are looking for a smudge-proof pencil liner, I recommend giving this product a try.