Beauty People Ironclad Woman Doll Eye Creamy Fit Liner / Doll Eye Black

It is a twist-up eyeliner, so it is a bit difficult to apply thin lines because it is blunt, but it is soft, making it great for filling in the gaps between the lashes. Since it is black, it gives the eyes a sharp, defined look. It is waterproof and sets the makeup, so it has good staying power without smudging. I tried rubbing it after it dried, and there was absolutely no smudging.