I purchased No. 2 Muted Brown and No. 3 Hazel Maroon. In the photo, the Clio Sharp So Simple Eyeliner in brown is on the far left, Muted Brown is in the middle, and Hazel Maroon is on the right. Muted Brown is darker than I expected..! If there had been a shade somewhere between No. 2 and No. 3, I think it would have become my holy grail product..! Still, it applies smoothly and looks natural, so I think I will use it often!