I recommend Amelie Sepia.

I recently purchased Amelie's Step Basic line's Sepia after seeing an acquaintance using it. As you can see from the swatch, it is a beautiful shade with a deep brown color and subtle shimmer. It is a great product for those who want to soften a very sharp eyeliner look or for those for whom black eyeliner does not suit them. I also like that it helps maintain the line for a long time, even if it tends to smudge due to oil, and allows you to add shading.