Recommended for Spring Warm undertones: Clio Sharp So Simple Waterproof Pencil Liner in Brown

My personal color is Spring Warm Bright.

In my case, heavy eye makeup doesn't suit me, so I use brown shades and apply them lightly only to the outer corners!

My eye area is quite oily, so my eyeliner tends to smudge easily, but the Clio pencil liner smudges less than others, and the price is reasonable, so I recommend it!