Sunscreen white cast

The sunscreen I used to use was reformulated, but when I applied it, it gradually turned an earthy, grayish color over time. I tried putting on makeup after applying the sunscreen, and maybe because of the sunscreen, an grayish tint started showing up in the evening.

The sunscreen I used before was ivory-colored? It kept my skin looking really pretty even after time passed... I really wasted my money. Can sunscreen really turn this grayish?

Please recommend an ivory-toned sunscreen.