I'm so confused about personal color.

Hello... I've recently become interested in personal color analysis and have been looking into various things. Since I see my own face all the time, I can't really figure it out objectively, so I decided to post this to ask for your opinions on what type you generally consider to be in cases like this.

I think I'm probably somewhere between a Cool Summer and a Light Spring (I don't suit things that are too cool, but if it's too warm, I look hot...).

When I apply reddish-toned eyeshadow for shading, from a distance it looks like puppy tear stains... it looks a bit messy and heavy. Since my skin isn't fair, the color doesn't show up very well with light-toned, milky eyeshadow, but it still looks better than wearing heavy makeup with reddish eyeshadow.

I thought it was a muted shade...? But the dull-toned shadows look like I've applied cement.

If anyone happens to be similar to me, I’m asking what personal color analysis you used and if you have any product recommendations.