Arm & Hammer toothpaste... Is there a similar toothpaste?

I've been using Arm & Hammer toothpaste for years now, and I've gotten so used to its intensity that I can't use any other toothpaste.

If I wipe it with something else, it feels like it hasn't been cleaned properly...

Is there any toothpaste with a similar texture?

I want to try changing my toothpaste! Haha.