I recommend Kiss Me mascara.

It feels like Kiss Me mascara has been out for quite a while—I don't remember exactly, but I think I've been using it for over ten years. I prefer a mascara that applies thickly and holds the curl well. Before this product, I used Maybelline mascara, but while it gave a voluminous finish, it smudged really badly under my eyes. Since this product addresses that drawback, I am extremely satisfied with it.