I recommend the [Etude] Idol Real Lash Fixer. I have been using this product since before it was renewed. True to its name, it makes your lashes look full and bold, just like a natural, bare-faced look! It doesn't smudge at all! If you apply this before mascara, your lashes curl up even better. It is my secret weapon that absolutely must not be discontinued; it is the best value for money!!