Failure - Dear Dahlia Blooming Edition Lip Paradise Color Balm

This is the Dear Dahlia Blooming Edition Lip Paradise Color Balm in Cindy. The color clumps a bit more than I expected, so I don't find myself reaching for it often. I bought this shade because I use the other colors well, but I regret not just buying the lighter shades. Haha. It is moisturizing, but it's a shame that the color comes out a bit clumpy.