Cat-face vs. Dog-face makeup

I want to do cat-eye makeup, but everyone says puppy-eye makeup suits my face better, so I'm conflicted.

I'm creating a cat-eye look by drawing the eyeliner with an upward flick at the outer corner. I'm also smudging a lot with eyeshadow on purpose!

Anyway, I spend the most time on my eye makeup. I want to accentuate my eyes to look a bit fierce.

But everyone keeps asking me why I draw my eyeliner so high. They say puppy makeup would suit me better.

Should I change my makeup routine? What do the experts think...😥