Squeaky-clean cleansing foam vs. Moisturizing cleansing foam

I always used the Neutrogena one (yellow packaging) because I really loved how squeaky clean it felt after washing.

But the foam cleanser I received as a gift and tried left my skin feeling genuinely moisturized after use. So moisturizing that I wondered if I hadn't even washed it off?

But actually, that kind of moisture wasn't bad at all.

Which cleansing foam do you prefer?

Squeaky clean feeling? Moisturizing feeling??