If I were to choose my tone among personal color eye makeup
Autumn Whim I have a natural skin tone, but since I've only ever used black eyeliner, I'm not sure if that's my personal color. I have fine double eyelids, so my eye makeup tends to smudge easily; therefore, my top priority is for an eyeliner that draws thin lines and doesn't smudge. I've tried many different products, but the Giverny All Day Matte Fit Liner has the strongest staying power and is the best.