I recommend the Aritaum eye pencil.

My number one pick among gel eyeliners is definitely the Aritaum Eye Doll Waterproof Eye Pencil.

It's waterproof, so it doesn't wash off easily with water, and

It also tends to smudge less.

It has a slight shimmer, so the color isn't too dark.

Above all, it spreads smoothly and does not irritate the eyes.

I really like Bali.